By Ben Samples, OneTankMedia

Stuffed lions, marble sculptures, Victorian art … and shrunken heads.

Welcome to the Lightner Museum.

JR Dental General, Specialty and Dental lab

Located deep within the heart of downtown St. Augustine, the Lightner is incredibly unique — both from within and without.

Built in 1888, the Lightner Museum was originally the Alcazar Hotel. Containing its own steam room, bowling alley, archery range and tennis court, the Alcazar attracted upper-class guests who preferred the highest level of decadence.

Once the Great Depression forced the Alcazar to shut its doors, Otto Lightner purchased the hotel in 1946 and used it as a literal storehouse for his immense collection of art and antiques.

But Lightner’s collection is anything but ordinary; it contains art made from human hair, intricately designed salt and pepper shakers, beautiful Tiffany glass and, yes, shrunken heads.

“When people ask me ‘What’s in here?’ what I always tell people is that this is a museum of collections,” said Emily Dietz, a student of Flagler College who interns at the Lightner. “What sets the Lightner apart is just the collections themselves. Literally, what we have here is anything and everything from all over the world.”

The museum is made up of three floors, but to say that each floor has its own distinct theme would be an overstatement.

As a general rule, the first floor is made up of Victorian-era antiques, including a collection of dolls and pianos … but visitors will also find a mummy, a stuffed turkey and a hodgepodge of unrecognizable, yet fascinating scientific contraptions.

On the second floor is a collection of beautiful glass art — along with a bathhouse that was once utilized during the building’s hotel years. And on the third floor, visitors will see fine art from the Victorian era, huge, incredibly detailed furniture — and when they look down, they will see an enormous pool that has been emptied and turned into a restaurant.

No matter the odd nature of the collection, there is no denying the rich history that permeates the museum as a whole. As visitors walk through each exhibit, it’s as if they’re seeing random, sometimes bizarre snapshots of an era long past.

“It’s fascinating to see the way they used to live, and I think it was such an elegant era, [that] we’ve forgotten about,” said Diedre Young, a visitor to the Lightner.

When asked about her favorite piece in the museum, she was, quite understandably, unsure.

“I wouldn’t say there’s only one,” remarked Young. “Some of it I don’t like at all — I either like it or I don’t.”

For those who are willing to take a chance on the Lightner, the admission is $10 for adults, $5 for students and young people, $6 for active military and free for children under 12.

People can also visit the Café Alcazar for a meal. With a menu of soups, salads, sandwiches and fresh seafood, the restaurant should satisfy most palettes.

And, as an added bonus, how many people can say that they’ve dined in restaurant that is located in the middle of a swimming pool?

Even if all of the fascinating eccentricities of the Lightner end up leaving you disappointed, Plan B could be only a block away. The museum is located in the middle of downtown St. Augustine — one of Florida’s most historic and tourist-friendly destinations.

The randomness of Lightner’s collection may prove to be maddening for some. But for those with a more offbeat taste, the Lightner is a fascinating treat that keeps them wondering what’s around the next corner.

Ben Samples is a senior studying multimedia journalism at the University of North Florida. He is a member of the One Tank Media team.

Photos courtesy Ben Samples, OneTankMedia

The Lightner’s exterior is just as grand as its interior.

OTM Lightner 1  Antique toy soldiers stand on guard as visitors walk through the first floor.

OTM Lightner 3   This fully stuffed lion is one of the first exhibits visitors pass by in Lightner’s bizarre collection.


  • Ackerman Urology We specialize in Prostate health, sexual health, bladder health, and Kidney health
  • Smiles by Glenos & Hadfic Orthodontists
  • I.T. Promise Inc. Computer Services Professional Computer Services business and residential
  • Pavers concrete and more Free estimates
  • Snip's Tree and stump service over 25 years experience
  • The right cleaners, LLC House cleaning services
  • Premier Homes Realty Inc. Michael Taylor and Tari Taylor
  • Quality Eye care 25+ years of experience
  • Vote Rod Hardwick for st johns county sheriff Working together for the strength of our community during challenging times
  • Preddy law firm estate planning, wills, trusts, probate, guardianship
  • Starling Nocatee, 360 degree virtual tour
  • Advertise in our May Issue The Creek Line
  • Staverman Hearing Centers Hear loud and clear
  • Support Community Journalism The Creek Line
  • Tutoring club of st johns. Text tutoring to 484848 for a chance to win one month of free tutoring
  • Being Well Florida News line is excited to introduce Being Well magazine
  • Westminster Woods on Julington creek. Live well. Be Happy
  • Ackerman cancer center. We're here for your cancer treatment
  • Anytime Fitness! Summer is Here! We Are Open!
  • Have questions about your medicare benefits? Call a SHINE volunteer.
  • Forever Vets Animal Hospital coupon for free exam and discount on preventative care for dogs and cats!
  • Ellegant earth solutions complete lawn maintenance with 28 years experience, complete lawn maintenance
  • Prudential Financial Planning Services with Andrew Laino
  • Support Community Journalism in Ponta Vedra NewsLine
  • Vote for Dr. Erick Aguilar Republican candidate U.S. House Fl 4th district
  • Academy of Dance Open House & Registration August 19th and 20th 3pm to 6pm Classes start August 24th! Ballet, Pointem Jazz, Hip Hop Contemporary, Modern, Lyrical, Music Theatre, Vocal
  • Affordable Water
  • All About Ballroom
  • Do you only want cremation?
  • Craig Funeral services, Funeral, Crematory, Memorial Park
  • Cronin Ace Hardware
  • Vote for Christian Whitehurst! for St. Johns county commissioner, District 1
  • Doug Nunnery, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices,
  • Finding the right doctor just got easier, Dr. Levine Baptist primary care
  • DIscount up to 30% Jim Register state farm agent
  • Nemetz Dental Associates! Your new smile awaits!
  • Deerwood Academy register now for 2020-2021 VPK
  • Eye center of st augustine, The eye surgery Center of St Augustine
  • Famous Automotive and tire center
  • Fruit Cove Baptist Church
  • The Goddard School summer camp
  • Havana Printing and office supply Call us today for all your cutome printing needs
  • Ian MacDonald Mortgage loan originator with Regions Mortgage
  • Julington Creek Chiropractic & Wellness Center P.A. serving st. johns county for nearly 21 years
  • Future home loans. North Florida's Premier Mortgage Expert Ryan Proffitt
  • Let them know you are open for business! Advertise in our May Issue! Ponta Vedra NewsLine
  • Wild Birds Unlimited Nature shop. Have you watered your birds lately?
  • Legends of Real Estate call Kim Kessler
  • Creeks Air Conditioning & Heating. We service all makes and models for residential and commerical!
  • Crosswinds Veterinary Hospital. Preventative Medicine and wellness, Surgery, Dentistry, Labs and Imaging, Farm Animal Medicine, In-Patient and Emergency Care
  • Deborah Lennon, AAMS. Edward Jones Making sense of investing
  • Florida Waterways Inc. Your trusted Waterway Advisers
  • Harbor Chase Independent & Assisted living Memory Care Mandarin. Immerse yourself in a rewarding community that enriches your body, mind, and soul.
  • JJs Bistro $10 off lunch or dinner
  • Dont Forget to vote for John Turner School Board member
  • Julington Creek Family Dentistry. Implant Cosmetic and Restoration Dentistry. We are following Advanced Safety protocols set forth by CDC, OSHA and ADA guidelines for dental practices
  • Lori Hershey for School Board, District 7. A school system we can all believe in.
  • Alicia Washington for Circuit Judge
  • Matt Schellenberg. Dependable Leadership for these challenging Times. School Board District 7
  • Re-elect Mike Orfinger for circuit judge
  • Concrete Works! Free Estimates, driveways, Patios, Walkways, Concrete removal, Driveway extension, Pavers
  • Family Remodeling Contractors! Bath, Kitchen &ADA Remodeling
  • Mobile Notary Service. 15 years experience, 24 hour services
  • River Garden Senior Services, However and whenever you need us we're here
  • Starlight Gymnastics! Our #1 priority is your children!
  • Chris Strickland for ST Johns county sheriff!
  • Sugar Bear Antique Mall Summer spectacular sale July 10th-12th
  • Baptist Health, Great tools for motherhood
  • A Green Cleaner, Free pickup and delivery to your home!
  • Let them know you are open for business! Advertise in our May Issue!
  • Luxury living and compassionate care come together at starling. Welcome Home.
  • Tailored living Premier Garage solutions
  • Westminster St. Augustine. were here when you need us
  • Alive Credit Union Start banking healthier today!
  • Clara's Tidbits Now in Mandarin!
  • Brian E. Floro DMD, PA Dental services
  • JR Dental General, Specialty and Dental lab
  • Support community journalism! Subscribe to the Mandarin Newsline today!
  • Railing Chiropractic & Acupuncture
  • Let them know you are open for business! Advertise in our may issue!
  • Dottie Lay. When selling or buying choose the top sales agent that works for you!
  • HarborChase independent & assisted living Memory Care Mandarin. Your safety and peace of mind is always our Top Priority
  • Fieldd Cadillac of St. Augustine
  • Advertise your business in The CreekLine!
  • Bring your print projects to us! The UPS Store
  • Westminster St. Augustine Gracious living a world apart
  • Willie Jewell's BBQ! Every meal comes with a side of southern hospitality
  • Advertise your business in The CreekLine!
  • Advertise your business in The CreekLine!
  • Advertise your business in The CreekLine!
  • Smart Choice Medical healthcare membership! No VoPay, No Deductibles, No Hassles
  • Havana Printing 904-447-5021